When you commit to furnishing an intentional home, you are making a choice to reject disposable culture. For lovers of Arts & Crafts design, that choice often comes down to two recognized standards of excellence: Stickley and Amish-built Mission and Craftsman furniture.
Both paths lead to heirloom-quality pieces rooted in the early 20th-century Craftsman movement. Both prioritize the natural beauty of wood and the integrity of visible joinery. But when it comes to curating a space that feels uniquely yours, it really comes down to an understanding of the difference between factory-scale legacy and artisan-built flexibility.
Here is how to navigate the choice between the two.
The Stickley Legacy: Large-Scale Craftsmanship
There is no denying the historical weight of the Stickley name. Gustav Stickley was instrumental in bringing the Arts & Crafts movement to the American mainstream by championing straightforward designs that celebrated the materials themselves.
The Stickley catalog still comprises classic Arts & Crafts designs, in a limited number of quintessentially Mission finishes, staying true to the original look of the designs.
Today, Stickley continues its legacy out of two primary, large-scale facilities in New York and North Carolina. They utilize an impressive blend of modern precision technology - like x-raying wood for defects - and hundreds of skilled factory artisans to produce their recognized catalog of heirloom furniture. If Stickley were alive today, he’d approve of the use of technology for heavy, repetitive work that ultimately frees up artisans to focus on structural joinery, hand-finishing and final details.
If you are looking for a widely respected, historic brand name and are happy selecting from a standardized menu of finishes and fabrics, Stickley delivers beautiful, reliable craftsmanship.
Amish-Built Excellence: The Independent Workshop
Where Amish-built furniture truly stands apart is in the scale of the workshop and the depth of customization. At Modern Bungalow, our Mission and Craftsman collections are not built in a 400,000-square-foot facility; they are bench-built by independent, generational craftspeople in small family workshops.
This approach shifts the focus from brand-name manufacturing to a tactile, living artisan tradition. When an artisan builds a piece in a small-batch setting, the result is furniture with a distinct soul and unmatched structural integrity.
Explore our Craftsman Style Bedroom Furniture Collection or Mission Living Room Collection
The Core Differences
When comparing the two, the decision usually comes down to four key factors:
-
Construction and Joinery: Both Stickley and high-end Amish builders utilize authentic, time-tested techniques like mortise-and-tenon joinery and dovetail drawers. However, independent Amish builders meticulously hand-select and match boards to ensure the grain flows beautifully across wide surfaces, like a dining room tabletop or a solid wood headboard.
-
Flexibility of Style: Do you love the craftsmanship but not always the dark finishes? Do you want to mix up the Mission look with cherry wood in a light finish, in order to pair it with your modern rugs and upholstered furniture? Any Amish piece can be built in any wood, in any finish to allow you to take the Craftsman aesthetic into the 21st century.
If you love the heavier, historically strict look of traditional Mission Revival, Stickley is a beautiful choice. At Modern Bungalow, we take a slightly different approach. Our Amish builders use those classic Craftsman silhouettes and update them for the modern home.
-
True Customization: This is the most significant differentiator. Because Stickley operates on a massive production line, they offer what we call "catalog customization.” You can choose from their specific menu of dimensions and finishes. Amish workshops offer true, individualized customization. Need a dining table scaled down by three inches to fit the exact footprint of your dining room? Want to tweak the height of a headboard to clear a window frame? Amish artisans accommodate these intentional, structural changes seamlessly.
Shop Custom Solid Wood Dining Tables
-
The Finish: Our Amish builders utilize catalyzed conversion varnishes. This hand-applied finish provides incredible resistance to water rings, heat, and daily life, while highlighting the deep, tactile beauty of the wood grain rather than masking it beneath a heavy topcoat. At Stickley, their standard finish is an industrial solvent-based lacquer. Lacquer is infinitely repairable but will ultimately require more care. A sweating glass of ice water will leave a water ring.
Which Is Right for Your Home?
If your goal is to own a piece with a famous historic brand name and you love the classic Mission aesthetic and can work with their catalog dimensions, Stickley is a wonderful, high-quality choice.
If you are looking to invest in artisan-made furniture that can be tailored to the exact dimensions and aesthetic of your space, Amish-built furniture offers a more personalized experience. It is not just about buying a chair or a table; it is about curating a legacy piece that will be passed down through your family.
Discover the Best Wood Species for Craftsman Furniture
Experience the Craftsmanship in Store
Furniture of this caliber is meant to be felt. We invite you to visit the Modern Bungalow showroom at 1028 South Gaylord in Denver to run your hands along the quarter-sawn oak, test the comfort of our handcrafted-to-order seating, and let us help you design a home that feels like a true sanctuary.
